Oakleafe Claims - Logo
Oakleafe Claims

Arbitration: A Guide for Insurance Claimants and Policyholders

Insurance Claim Management, Insurance Loss Assessors, Loss Assessor

When it comes to resolving disputes in the UK, particularly those related to Insurance Claims, arbitration acts as an important mechanism. This method offers a non-binding alternative to traditional court proceedings, allowing parties to settle disagreements more efficiently. For insurance policyholders and claimants, understanding the nuances of arbitration is essential for informed decision-making.

What is Arbitration in the UK?

Arbitration in the UK is a process where disputing parties agree to have their conflict resolved by an arbitrator. Unlike court judges, arbitrators are often experts in the field related to the dispute, making them particularly advantageous in complex insurance matters.

What is an Arbitrator ?

An Arbitrator is a impartial third party who liaises between the two parties involved in the Claim enabling all to come to a non binding agreement. They are generally of a professional statue and knowledgeable in the field applicable.

Mediation vs. Arbitration - in simple terms

Arbitration is a process in which a decision is made when a third party works with both parties to agree to a settlement without needing to follow court proceedings.

Mediation is a process that happens when neither of the parties can come to an agreement, so the claim is taken further to involve court procedures.

Legally Binding Nature of Arbitration

One of the critical aspects of arbitration is its potentially legally binding nature. In the UK, the Arbitration Act 1996 underpins this process, ensuring that the arbitrator's decision is enforceable, much like a court judgment IF both parties agree to accepting this prior to the procedure taking place. This feature is particularly crucial in insurance claims where final dispute is desired.

Disadvantages of Arbitration

Despite its benefits, arbitration has drawbacks. Firstly, the cost can be significant, as parties bear the arbitrator's fees and potentially legal representation. Secondly, the lack of a formal appeals process means decisions are final, which can be a double-edged sword for disputing parties.

Role of a Loss Assessor like Oakleafe

The above information is a guideline only. We advise hiring a loss assessor like Oakleafe Claims. As Europe's largest Loss Assessor, we bring expertise in handling insurance claims, helping policyholders navigate the arbitration process, present strong cases, and understand the implications of the arbitrator's decision. Their role can be crucial in maximising the chances of a favourable outcome.


Arbitration in the UK presents many opportunities and challenges for insurance claimants and policyholders. Understanding its workings, benefits, and limitations is vital to making informed decisions. In this journey, the support of a seasoned loss assessor can be invaluable, offering guidance and expertise in what can often be a complex and daunting process.

Related Claims and Topics
March 28, 2024
How to Protect Your Rental Property with Landlord Insurance.

Are you a landlord looking to safeguard your rental property and investment? Landlord insurance is a vital tool that provides protection and peace of mind against various risks and liabilities associated with renting out a property. In this guide, we'll explore everything you need to know about landlord insurance in the UK, including what it […]

Read More
March 26, 2024
Essential Home Insurance Tips for First-Time Buyers

Are you taking the exciting step of purchasing your first home? Congratulations! As you embark on this journey, one crucial aspect to consider is securing the right home insurance policy. Navigating the world of home insurance can seem daunting, but fret not – we've compiled a comprehensive guide tailored specifically for first-time buyers like you. […]

Read More
March 22, 2024
Is Your Home Spring Ready?

As spring approaches, the days become brighter and the weather warms. We look at ways to help prepare your home for the sunny season, ensuring it is in tip-top condition and helping to prevent winter wear and tear or spring showers causing issues that could result in you needing to make a Domestic Insurance Claim. […]

Read More


If you have been declined whilst trying to claim on your domestic or commercial insurance, we can help. We can also help with professional services, for example, Brokers, VAR Valuations and Managing Agents.