How to Claim Insurance After a Theft: Steps to Ensure a Successful Claim

How to claim insurance after a theft is one of the most common questions UK residents ask following a burglary. And it’s no surprise – getting it wrong can lead to delays, disputes, or even a reduced payout.

A break-in is more than just the loss of valuables. It’s a personal violation that leaves many feeling shaken and vulnerable. On top of the emotional impact, you’re faced with the daunting task of navigating an insurance process that can feel slow, unclear, and overwhelming.

But you don’t have to face it alone—or guess your way through it. Whether you’re dealing with stolen jewellery, a damaged door, or both, this guide will walk you through each critical step: from reporting the theft and gathering evidence to working with your insurer and securing the right support.

By the end, you’ll know exactly how to claim insurance after a theft, confidently, and without missing any key steps.

Immediate Steps After Theft

The first few hours after a theft are critical. Acting fast can help police investigations and safeguard your insurance claim.

1. Call the Police

• Dial 999 in emergencies or your local non-emergency number for less urgent cases.
• Provide detailed information: what was stolen, where it happened, and any suspicious activity.
• Request a crime reference number – this is essential for your insurance claim.

2. Secure Your Property

If there has been forced entry or damage:

• Board up broken doors or windows.
• Contact emergency repair services if needed.
• Take clear photographs of all damage before repairs.
• Keep receipts for emergency fixes – these are claimable.

Documenting the Loss

Good documentation is your strongest ally in a successful claim.

Create an Inventory

• For each stolen or damaged item, list:
• Item description and model
• Estimated age
• Original purchase price
• Serial number (if available)

Collect Proof of Ownership

• Receipts or invoices
• Bank or credit card statements
• Photos showing the items in your property
• Product packaging or manuals (as backup evidence)

Take Photographs

• Document all visible damage (doors, safes, storage areas)
• Capture multiple angles and contextual images

What Oakleafe Clients Say:

Book your complimentary consultation with our insurance claim professionals.

Our insurance claim professionals will explain the claim process to ensure you understand your options.

request a callback

How to Claim Insurance After a Theft: Contacting Your Insurer

Once you’ve reported the theft and documented your losses, it’s time to notify your insurer.

Notify Within the Policy Timeframe

Most insurance policies have clear deadlines for reporting incidents. Review your policy and ensure you file your claim within the specified timeframe to avoid rejection.

Choose a Contact Method

Insurers typically allow claims to be filed via:

• Telephone through a dedicated claim line, or
  Online claim forms accessible via their website or app.

Having your policy number, crime reference number, and documentation ready will simplify the process.

Role of a Loss Assessor

If your claim appears complex, you might benefit from hiring a loss assessor. They:

• Work independently on your behalf (unlike the insurer-appointed loss adjuster).
• Ensure your claim is accurately prepared and optimise the chances of receiving fair compensation.
• Negotiate with the insurer to represent your interests.

While assessors take a fee (often a percentage of the claim settlement), their expertise can drastically increase the likelihood of a successful claim.

Understanding Your Policy Cover

Knowing your policy details is key when learning how to claim insurance after a theft, especially when it comes to what’s covered and what’s not.

Types of Cover

• Contents Insurance ensures your belongings are covered for incidents like theft or damage.
• Buildings Insurance covers structural elements, such as damaged windows or doors caused during a break-in.
• Off-Premises Cover might apply, depending on your policy terms, if items were stolen outside your home.

Common Exclusions

Be aware of typical exclusions that may affect your claim:

• High-value jewellery or electronics might need separate declarations on your policy.
• Items stolen by members of your household or left unsecured.
• Theft without evidence of forced entry.

Refer to your policy schedule to identify other potential exclusions.

Working Through the Claim

The claim process involves submitting your documentation and working with your insurer to achieve a settlement. Here’s what to expect.

Submit Documentation

Provide all the necessary paperwork, including:

• Claim form (accessed via your insurer’s platform).
• A detailed inventory, accompanied by supporting documents such as receipts and photographs.
• Quotes or invoices for any emergency repairs that have already been performed.

Adjuster or Loss Assessor Visit

Your insurer’s loss adjuster may visit your property to:

• Validate your claim.
• Assess the extent of damage or loss.
• Review the documentation you’ve provided.

If you’ve hired a loss assessor, they will liaise with the adjuster on your behalf.

Settlement or Rejection

Once all details are reviewed, the insurer will:

1. Offer a settlement amount to compensate your losses. This will reflect deductions for policy excess and depreciation (where applicable).
2. Reject your claim if it doesn’t meet policy terms. Common reasons include late reporting, inadequate documentation, or exclusions for theft.

If your claim is rejected, request specific reasons and, if necessary, appeal the decision with additional supporting evidence.

Preventing Future Theft

Experiencing theft can be distressing, but implementing security measures can reduce the likelihood of future incidents.

Improve Your Home Security

Consider upgrading your home’s security setup:

• Install robust locks on doors and windows.
• Add smart home alarms and CCTV cameras for real-time monitoring.
• Use motion-activated lighting around entry points to deter intruders.

Join a Neighbourhood Watch Scheme

Collaborating with local residents in a community-based initiative can:

• Increase crime reporting and monitoring in your area.
• Create a visible deterrent for would-be thieves.

Check Your Insurance Coverage

Now is a good time to revisit your policy terms:

• Ensure all valuable items are adequately declared.
• Consider policy upgrades for additional coverage, such as personal belongings protection for items carried outside the home.

Take Back Control After a Theft – One Step at a Time

Recovering from a theft is never easy, but with the right approach, you can take back control and increase your chances of a successful insurance claim. Acting fast, staying organised, and understanding your insurance cover makes a big difference.

Here’s a quick recap of what you should do:

• Report the theft to the police immediately and get a crime reference number.
• Secure your home and document all visible damage before any repairs.
• Gather proof of ownership like receipts and photos.
• Inform your insurer within the claim deadline, with your documents ready.
• Hire a loss assessor if your claim is large or complicated – they work for you, not the insurer.
• Review your policy’s exclusions carefully to avoid surprises.
• Invest in better home security and review your policy to ensure it’s up to date.

If you’re feeling overwhelmed or unsure what your insurer might cover, Oakleafe Claims can help. Our expert loss assessors handle the heavy lifting, fight your corner, and ensure your claim is maximised. Don’t leave your payout to chance – speak to a professional today and get the support you deserve.

We Can Help

Oakleafe Claims have represented policyholders and managed their insurance claims since before the First World War. We have vast expertise and experience in both domestic and commercial insurance claims with thousands of satisfied policyholders who have received their deserved insurance settlement. With no upfront fees required, our internal data shows that insurance claims managed by professional loss assessors like Oakleafe can expect a settlement up to 40% higher than claims managed by the policyholder.

What Oakleafe Clients Say: