When business operations are disrupted, the financial impact can be significant, and business interruption insurance exists to address this challenge. However, the process of filing a claim doesn’t always go smoothly. Disputes over business interruption claims are becoming increasingly common, often stemming from unclear policy terms and differing interpretations of the losses incurred.
This article will explore the common causes of these disputes, actionable strategies to resolve them, and preventive steps to minimise future conflicts. Understanding how to manage these claims effectively can help ensure your business remains financially secure through difficult times.
Disputes over business interruption insurance claims typically arise from misunderstandings or disagreements between policyholders and insurers. Here are some of the most frequent causes of conflict.
Ambiguous Policy Language
Insurance policies are often complex, with vague or unclear language leaving room for interpretation. This can lead to disagreements about what the policy does and does not cover. For example, phrases like “direct physical loss” or “ordinary payroll expenses” can cause confusion and trigger disputes, especially if the policyholder and insurer interpret them differently.
Coverage Exclusions and Limitations
Many policies include exclusions or limitations that may not be immediately apparent to the policyholder. Businesses often file claims thinking certain incidents are covered, only to learn later that their policy excludes specific causes, such as pandemics or cyber-attacks.
Disagreements on Loss Quantification
Calculating the financial losses caused by a business interruption is rarely straightforward. Disputes often arise from estimates of lost income, additional expenses, and recovery time. Insurers may have different methodologies for evaluating these figures, leading to disagreements with the policyholder.
Delayed Claim Processing
Some disputes occur because claims aren’t processed promptly. Policyholders may feel that insurers are using delay tactics, further compounding the business’s financial struggles, while insurers may argue that they are conducting thorough investigations.
Differing Interpretations of the Cause of Interruption
Insurers sometimes deny claims if they argue that the cause of the interruption doesn’t fall within the scope of coverage. For instance, disputes may arise if a business closes due to flooding, but the insurer attributes the damages to poor maintenance.
If disagreements over coverage or policy terms occur, there are several strategies you can employ to address the issue effectively.
Review Your Insurance Policy
Start by thoroughly reviewing your policy document. Understanding your coverage’s exact terms, conditions, and exclusions is essential. Highlight any ambiguous language that could be open to interpretation.
Seek Expert Consultation
Insurance advisors, legal professionals, or claim consultants can help clarify complex policy terms. They may also identify any unfair practices on the insurer’s part, providing you with actionable advice tailored to your case.
Assert Your Policyholder Rights
Policyholders have rights, including the right to receive a prompt and fair claims evaluation. Familiarising yourself with these rights can help when negotiating with insurers.
Address Common Areas of Dispute
Focus on the common triggers for coverage disputes, including indemnity periods (the duration for which business interruption losses are compensated) and excluded events. Ensure all relevant evidence supports your claim.
Explore Alternative Dispute Resolution
If the insurer and policyholder cannot agree, mediation or arbitration (explored further below) may be necessary. These alternatives often provide quicker resolutions than traditional legal routes.
What Oakleafe Clients Say:
If disagreements over coverage or policy terms occur, there are several strategies you can employ to address the issue effectively.
Review Your Insurance Policy
Start by thoroughly reviewing your policy document. Understanding your coverage’s exact terms, conditions, and exclusions is essential. Highlight any ambiguous language that could be open to interpretation.
Seek Expert Consultation
Insurance advisors, legal professionals, or claim consultants can help clarify complex policy terms. They may also identify any unfair practices on the insurer’s part, providing you with actionable advice tailored to your case.
Assert Your Policyholder Rights
Policyholders have rights, including the right to receive a prompt and fair claims evaluation. Familiarising yourself with these rights can help when negotiating with insurers.
Address Common Areas of Dispute
Focus on the common triggers for coverage disputes, including indemnity periods (the duration for which business interruption losses are compensated) and excluded events. Ensure all relevant evidence supports your claim.
Explore Alternative Dispute Resolution
If the insurer and policyholder cannot agree, mediation or arbitration (explored further below) may be necessary. These alternatives often provide quicker resolutions than traditional legal routes.
What Oakleafe Clients Say:
To resolve disputes around quantifying business interruption losses, employ the following strategies.
Provide Comprehensive Financial Records
Accurate and detailed financial records are essential when calculating losses. Include profit and loss statements, tax returns, and cash flow reports to substantiate your claim.
Use Forensic Accounting
Forensic accountants specialise in evaluating business interruption losses. They use financial records to accurately calculate lost income, additional operational costs, and recovery timelines. This independent analysis can strengthen your negotiation position.
Seek Independent Appraisals
If you disagree with your insurer’s assessment, consider obtaining an independent appraisal. Neutral experts can provide unbiased evaluations to establish the true extent of your losses.
Understand Areas of Contention
Some common sticking points include projections of future income and required recovery time. Ensure your projections are reasonable and backed by evidence, such as historical financial data.
Businesses often turn to legal or alternative dispute resolution methods when the situation escalates and an agreement cannot be reached.
Mediation
Mediation involves a neutral third-party mediator who helps negotiate a settlement between the policyholder and insurer. It’s a less adversarial and more cost-effective approach than going to court.
Arbitration
Arbitration is a formal process in which a neutral arbitrator examines the evidence and makes a binding decision. Many insurance policies include arbitration clauses requiring disputes to be settled this way.
Litigation
If other methods fail, litigation may be necessary. Taking the matter to court can be time-consuming and costly but may lead to a fair resolution. Preparing for litigation involves thorough documentation, legal representation, and a clear understanding of the claim’s value.
Each method has its pros and cons, which should be carefully evaluated based on the specifics of your dispute.
The best way to handle disputes is to prevent them from occurring. Consider these proactive measures.
Opt for Clear Policy Language
Work with an insurance expert to ensure your policy terms are unambiguous and cover your business’s specific needs.
Keep Thorough Documentation
Maintain detailed financial records, including income statements and expense tracking. This will make quantifying losses easier if you need to file a claim.
Schedule Regular Policy Reviews
Businesses evolve over time, and your insurance policy should reflect that. Review and update your coverage regularly to ensure it remains relevant.
Maintain Open Communication with Your Insurer
Building a strong relationship with your insurer and maintaining ongoing communication can help resolve potential issues early.
Business interruption claim disputes can be stressful and financially damaging, but they can be effectively managed and resolved with the right strategies. By understanding common causes, using expert resources, and adopting preventive measures, small business owners can protect their financial stability and confidently continue operations.
If you’re currently facing a dispute, consider consulting a professional specialising in insurance claim resolution to strengthen your case and ensure a fair outcome. Taking the time to address disputes properly can safeguard your business’s future.
Oakleafe Claims have represented policyholders and managed their insurance claims since before the First World War. We have vast expertise and experience in both domestic and commercial insurance claims with thousands of satisfied policyholders who have received their deserved insurance settlement. With no upfront fees required, our internal data shows that insurance claims managed by professional loss assessors like Oakleafe can expect a settlement up to 40% higher than claims managed by the policyholder.
What Oakleafe Clients Say:
Please complete the form and one of our insurance claim professionals will call you back ASAP
